Bumbo Floor Seat vs. Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up
Which one is the Best for your baby?
Bumbo Floor Seat vs. Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up
Which one is the Best for your baby?
Baby floor seats are popular and essential babies accessories. They act as supporting tools for infants who are unable or still learning to sit up well.
These seats encourage babies to use their back and neck muscles while allowing them to sit in upright posture without laying down.
The two common types of baby floor seats are the Bumbo Floor seat and Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up floor seats. With the many reviews and features of these two infant floor seats, it’s easy to wonder which one is the most suitable seat for your baby.
Well, we provide everything you need to know about the best baby floor seats, plus a comprehensive comparison between the most popular floor seats: Bumbo floor seat and Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up to help you decide which one is the best floor seat for your child.
Bumbo Seat | Sit-Me-Up | |
Baby Floor Seat's Image |  |  |
Safety | 3-point harness | Steady and a closed structure |
Seat Base | Sturdy base | Wide base and soft fabrics |
Back and Shoulder Support | Has a lower seatback which may not offer enough shoulder and neck support. | Highly raised seat back for maximum shoulder and neck support |
Leg Holes and Legs Support | may not be suitable for chunkier infants | Allows baby legs to extend fully and their legs are entirely supported by the floor. |
Design | Many bright colors | Various patterns and colors with fun and attractive themes and prints for kids |
Accessories | Not included | Detachable snack/play tray and linkable toys. |
Washable | Simple to clean | Detachable and machine washable seat cover |
Weight Capacity | Up to 22lbs | Up to 25lbs |
Table of Contents
What's a Floor Baby Seat?
Before digging into the comparison of the Bumbo floor seat and Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up floor seat, it’d be best to know what’s a floor seat and if your kid needs one.
A floor baby seat will allow your child to see the beauty of the world in different point of views.
After several months, your baby will start learning to prop to a sitting position. This process can be more manageable and easier for them if they use a floor seat.
The Bumbo floor seat has been in the market for decades now. It comes with fun features and many bright colors suitable for kids of both genders.
It’s constructed using a robust and durable foam material to ensure your child’s comfort.
It also contains a removable tray to keep other baby add-ons and a 3-point harness to hold your child firmly and safely.
This Bumbo chair is recommendable for babies at 3-9 months of age with muscle strength who can comfortably and independently support their heads.
Pros
- It’s simple to clean
- It’s highly portable
- It comes in many bright colors
- It has a sturdy base
- It has a strong safety harness
Cons
- It may not be suitable for chunkier infants
- It does not support baby legs fully
- It has a lower seatback which may not offer enough shoulder and neck support.
This seat floor is constructed to sit on flat surfaces only.
It comes in various patterns and colors with fun and attractive themes and prints for kids.
It has a wide base and soft fabrics for maximum comfort and support.
The seat has a removable cover that’s machine washable for easy cleaning.
The seat’s design allows kids to sit near the ground for their legs to be entirely supported by the floor.
The Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up baby floor seat will allow your child to fully stretch their legs without slightly hanging above the ground like when using the Bumbo floor seat.
It also has a more raised seat back with arm support that will encourage your child to explore different perspectives while offering them good head control and full shoulder support.
Pros
- A supportive upright seat that enables upright position with highly raised seat back for maximum shoulder and neck support
- Allows baby legs to extend fully
- It has a detachable and machine washable seat cover
- Ergonomic design for premium comfort
- It’s suitable even for kids with chunky legs
- It comes in many designs and bright colors
Cons
- It’s not as durable as the Bumbo seat floor
- It’s not highly portable.
Bumbo Floor Seat vs. Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up - Which one is the Best for your baby?
The most suitable seat floor for your child will differ with their needs and age.
Generally, the Fisher-Price Sit-Me-Up is the most recommendable choice for your child compared to the Bumbo floor seat.
Below is an extensive comparison between these two-floor seats to help you understand why we recommend the Fisher-Price floor seat.
Function and Design
The Bumbo seat comes with a sturdy foam, comes in different colors, sturdy harnesses, and a scooped-out seat that’s slightly raised from the ground. Its wide base is broad enough for high stability and a machine-washable seat cover for easy cleaning.
While all these features are essential in floor seats, the Bumbo chair has a design that can harm your baby’s development and tamper with your baby’s posture.
Its scooped-out seat design and leg holes firmly hold the child in one position, hence hindering their movements of lower extremities. This effect can put your baby’s hips and pelvis in an inappropriate place, causing them to have a rounded neck and squished back.
The locked position will limit your child from actively using the muscles necessary to develop fine sitting skills. Also, your baby’s secured legs will be slightly higher than the pelvis, which is not ideal.
Another drawback of the Bumbo seat is its leg holes are only for infants with lean/skinny thighs.
On the other hand, Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up comes with a soft, machine-washable fabric seat with a broad base for high baby support. It also has a variety of colors and designs that can easily fold. However, its footprint is relatively more prominent than the Bumbo seat.
Unlike the Bumbo infant seat, this Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up doesn’t limit baby movement. Its baby seat is closer to the ground to allow full strength of your baby’s legs. It also has a raised seat back for full-back and shoulder support.
Its leg holes are also bigger compared to the Bumbo seat, making it suitable for chunkier infants.
Cost
The Fisher-Price infant seat is more economical and cheaper to procure than the Bumbo seat. The Bumbo chair seat costs around $50-$60 minus the accessories, which can cost about $12-$35
in contrast, the price tag of Fisher-Price Sit-Me-UP is roughly $50, inclusive of the detachable snack tray and linkable toys.
Another essential aspect to consider when comparing prices is the seat’s use. The Bumbo’s small leg holes may not fit your baby thighs as they grow; hence Fisher-Price Sit-Me-Up still qualifies as the most recommendable one.
Accessories
The Bumbo infant seat comes with many accessories compared to the Fisher-Price infant seat. You can select from many options, including a seat cover, ground seat tray, and other toys.
However, while this seat has a feeding tray option, many parents show concerns about its design that puts a child in an inappropriate sitting position that can easily lead to choking.
On the other hand, Fisher-Price Sit-Me-UP comes with two toys like a teether and a rattle. Some types have small squeakers on the pad’s bottom. These add-ons are a great way to teach your child about cause and effect while kicking.
Weight Capacity
The Fisher Price Sit-Me-Up infant seat has a higher weight capacity than the Bumbo floor seat. The latter has weight limits and can hold 22lbs only, while the first can comfortably accommodate kids with up to 25lbs.
Alternative Baby Floor Seats
You can find other practical and high-end baby floor seats other than the two options discussed above.
Here are two other alternative baby seats you can consider other than the Fisher-Price Sit-Me-Up Baby seat:
This baby floor seat is another excellent alternative to the Fisher-Price floor seat. Like the Fisher-Price baby chair, this seat allows baby legs to sit on the ground and has a higher baby seat back for maximum back/shoulder support.
It also has a soft and comfortable seat pad with handing toys to keep your child entertained and engaged when sitting on it.
It contains a 360-degree rotating tray with other toys for more activities and fun for your child.
Its chair comes with harnesses for enhanced support with a soft foam pad for high comfort.
However, its leg holes can be somewhat smaller for chunkier babies.
This infant seat has a luxurious Boppy-like design that will leave your child comfortable and happy for hours.
It has two big leg holes and a raised seat back to fully support your child’s back/shoulders.
It’s an excellent choice for infants who are still trying to sit up and need slightly extra support.
It’s only suitable for floor use, not raised surfaces like couches and tables.
Essential Aspects to Consider When Using a Baby Floor Seat
While floor seats are useful baby accessories, overusing and misusing them can be detrimental to your baby’s development.
For proper and efficient use of these seats, it’s best to keep in mind the following things:
1. Adult supervision is critical.
2. Don’t use the seat for more than 30 minutes a day to prevent your child from relying on it too much and affect their progression to sitting self-sufficiently.
3. Tummy time is the most appropriate time for using a floor seat.
4. It’s best to use the baby floor seat when your child can support their head independently.
Conclusion
Best baby floor seats are essential gears to help babies learn to sit upright. However, they’re not a necessity to teach your baby to sit up.
But if you need or planning to procure an infant seat, then we’d recommend the Fisher-Price baby seat over the Bumbo seat due to its suitable design, convenience, and function.
Read also:
- Best Baby Walkers for Tall Babies in 2023
- Best Toys to Help Baby Stand in 2023
- 10 Best Baby Swing for Reflux and Colic In 2023
- Best Toys to help Toddlers Talk – Speech Development
- Best Baby Safety Helmets for Crawling in 2023
- 20 Best Climbing Toys for 1 Year Olds in 2023 (and Toddlers!)
- 10 Best Bouncy Toys for 1-Year-Olds in 2023
- Baby Walker vs. Baby Jumper – Which is better?
- The Best Wooden Scooters for Toddlers and Kids
- Best Wooden Balance Board for Toddlers and Kids in 2023
